The Magnus Archives takes the standard weekly horror anthology podcast format and gives it an exciting overhaul.
Instead of telling entirely isolated and otherwise unrelated stories, the show explores stories related to the many artifacts within the mysterious Magnus Archives, an institution built to house paranormal artifacts and study them.
Are you here because you’ve just finished binging the series, and now you need something new to listen to? Then you have come to the perfect place!
I’ve hunted around to find the best shows that are similar to the Magnus Archives so that you can more quickly fill the void left in its wake! Read on below to find out what these shows are.
Table of Contents
Knifepoint Horror
Knifepoint Horror does not play around in delivering quick and simple thrills to send chills coursing throughout your body.
Every episode of the show dives directly into the story and wastes no time with formal introductions, or opening ad reads.
The focus in this show is entirely on giving you the fix of fear that you crave.
Thanks to its fast-paced and intense storytelling style, the show has earned itself a healthy reputation. You’ll find yourself edging closer and closer to the edge of your seat as you listen.
The hosts know how to maximize tension at every single moment until it all becomes too much to bear.
Listen on knifepointhorror.libsyn.com.
The NoSleep Podcast
It’s remarkable what a little bit of music can do to ramp up the tension of a good story.
The NoSleep Podcast includes a very atmospheric soundtrack to accompany the stories told on it. This helps to make them feel all the more spine-tingling.
The show also includes a host who is incredibly talented at his craft. His delivery is smooth, and he knows how to get the right tone for each tale.
He’s able to keep the listener engaged from start to finish without losing their attention.
This is also helped by the fact that the show’s central goal, to tell the most horrifying and freaky stories around, is achieved wonderfully.
Listen on thenosleeppodcast.com.
I Am In Eskew
If you want a podcast show with a continuous storyline that spreads across the entire series, similar to The Magnus Archives, then check out I Am In Eskew.
This show follows a man trapped in the strange and paranormal city of Eskew, which he seemingly cannot find his way out of.
The show takes the form of audio diary recordings as the man explores the various goings-on in the city and how his mental state is slowly deteriorating.
The show is also gory and visceral, which makes it simply fantastic for horror fans who want something truly shocking.
Listen on iamineskew.com.
The Alexandria Archives
The framing device used in The Alexandria Archives shares some slight similarities to that used in The Magnus Archives.
The show takes place on a radio station based on the campus of Alexandria University.
Each episode is hosted by the enigmatic and ultimately quite charming Morning Wood, who takes us through the latest events at the university and delivers some of the genuinely creepy stories that lie dormant in the Alexandria Archives themselves.
This bizarre and crazy series will make for a perfect remedy for your Magnus Archives cravings.
The show is very similar but is different enough to be unique and stand up on its own merit.
Listen on alexandriaarchives.com.
The Truth
One thing that sets The Truth apart from its considerable competition is its ability to tell stories in a truly cinematic and epic manner.
Listening to the show feels like listening to a movie made just for your ears!
The show focuses on telling a different story in each episode, each with such an intensity that you won’t be able to help but become completely engrossed in the narrative.
It doesn’t matter what kinds of stories you are into because the show will appeal to everyone.
The show has a great sense of humor, which adds another layer of entertainment to the already impressive storytelling.
Listen on thetruthpodcast.com.
Spines
The central hook that drives Spines is straightforward but incredibly effective.
The story follows a young woman known as Wren who wakes up one morning suffering from amnesia, utterly unaware of her surroundings and how she could have gotten there.
Wren pieces together her strange past in each episode and discovers an unsettling and disturbing connection to an unusual cult.
What role did she play in the cult, and how did she end up losing her memories.
Right from the very first episode and until the epic finale, you won’t be able to pull yourself back from the edge of your seat.
Spines is a thrilling ride that will keep you guessing until its final moments.
Listen on spinespodcast.com.
The White Vault
There are perhaps a few things more creepy and terrifying than the thought of total and absolute isolation. That’s what makes the series The White Vault so immensely effective.
The show takes place in a remote research facility in the Arctic, where a bunch of proficient researchers are sent to repair some machine failures.
However, things are not quite what they seem at the outpost, and it quickly becomes apparent that they are not the only ones there.
This podcast has become renowned for its slow-burning nature as it slowly goes through the events of the story to build up tension and dread throughout.
If you have been searching for a show that will leave you feeling uneasy and unsettled, this podcast is for you.
Listen on thewhitevalut.com.
Lore Podcast
This bi-weekly podcast has become legendary thanks to its subject matter and how it explores it. Each episode features a two-fold story.
The episode starts by exploring a famous story, urban legend, or ancient myth and does so with storytelling pazzazz. This makes even some of the oldest stories feel incredibly fresh.
However, after the show has explored each story, it then explores the real-life stories that caused such stories to come to be.
This series can be a great way to appreciate some of the world’s favorite stories while also learning about some lesser-known stories that might have played a key role in bringing them to fruition.
Thus, as well as being entertaining and occasionally creepy, the show is also very educational and fulfilling.
Listen on lorepodcast.com.
